Falls from height remain one of the biggest killers in the UK construction industry. While much attention is rightly given to scaffolding, ladders, and edge protection, a significant and often overlooked hazard lies directly above us: fragile roofs.
Working on or near fragile roofs poses an exceptionally high risk, with tragic consequences if proper precautions aren't taken. As a company dedicated to construction health and safety, we frequently encounter scenarios where the dangers of fragile roofs are underestimated or misunderstood. This blog post aims to shed light on this critical issue, outlining the risks, legal requirements, and practical steps to prevent falls through fragile roofs.
What Constitutes a Fragile Roof?
The term "fragile roof" refers to any roof surface or part of a roof that would not safely support the weight of a person and anything they might be carrying. This can include, but is not limited to:
- Asbestos cement sheets: Especially older, weathered sheets.
- Roof lights/skylights: Often made of brittle plastic or glass.
- Fibre cement sheets: Similar to asbestos cement, these can become brittle with age.
- Corroded metal sheets: Rust can significantly weaken the structural integrity.
- Non-reinforced plastic sheets: Common in older agricultural buildings or lean-tos.
- Rotten timber decking: Particularly under felt roofs.
- Unsupported plasterboard ceilings: Where workers might step through from above.
It's crucial to remember that even a roof that appears robust can have fragile elements. Age, weather exposure, and previous damage can all compromise a roof's integrity.
The Alarming Statistics
The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) consistently highlights falls from height as a leading cause of fatalities and major injuries in construction. Falls through fragile roofs contribute significantly to these statistics. These incidents often result in severe, life-changing injuries or death, making prevention paramount.
Legal Obligations: The Work at Height Regulations 2005
The Work at Height Regulations 2005 are the cornerstone of legislation concerning work at height in the UK. They place a clear duty on employers (and those in control of work) to:
- Avoid work at height where possible: Can the work be done from the ground or using existing safe access?
- Where work at height cannot be avoided, prevent falls: This means using the right equipment and planning.
- Where falls cannot be prevented, minimise the distance and consequences of a fall: This involves using Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) and collective protective measures.
Specifically concerning fragile roofs, the regulations stipulate that no one should work on or near a fragile surface unless appropriate precautions have been taken.
Identifying Fragile Roofs
Before any work commences, a thorough Risk Assessment Method Statement (RAMS) is non-negotiable. This assessment must specifically identify all fragile roof areas. Key indicators include:
- Building age: Older buildings are more likely to have fragile roof materials.
- Roofing material type: Asbestos, fibre cement, and unreinforced plastics are immediate red flags.
- Visible damage: Cracks, corrosion, moss, or discolouration.
- Previous use: Agricultural buildings, warehouses, and industrial units often feature fragile roofs.
If there's any doubt about the fragility of a roof, it must be treated as fragile until proven otherwise. Signage should be clearly displayed to warn workers of fragile roof areas.
Preventing Falls: Practical Control Measures
Once identified, robust control measures must be implemented. These fall into a hierarchy of control, prioritising collective protection over individual measures:
1. Avoidance
- Inspect from below: Can the work (e.g. inspection, minor repair) be carried out using scaffolding, mobile elevating work platforms (MEWPs), or ladders from below the roof level?
- Remote inspection: Utilise drones or cameras for initial assessments.
You can learn more about the use of drones in construction in our blog post The Use of Drones in Construction Safety - An In-Depth Guide.
2. Collective Protective Measures (Preferred)
- Edge protection: If working near the edge of a fragile roof, guardrails and toe-boards are essential.
- Safety nets: Installed underneath the fragile roof surface to catch anyone who falls through. These must be correctly installed and regularly inspected.
- Work platforms/staging: Placing boards or staging over the fragile areas to distribute weight and provide a safe working surface. These must be securely fitted and extend across multiple roof supports.
- Crawling boards/roof ladders: Specifically designed to spread the load across roof purlins, allowing safe access across fragile materials. These are not a substitute for collective protection if prolonged work is required.
- Temporary total enclosures: For extensive work, a temporary roof structure can be built over the existing fragile roof, providing a completely safe working environment.
- Temporary covers: Install secure covers over fragile skylights or roof openings.
3. Personal Protective Equipment (PPE)
- Safety harnesses and lanyards: When collective measures are not reasonably practicable, or as a backup, individuals must be equipped with harnesses, lanyards, and suitable anchor points.
- Fall arrest systems: Designed to safely stop a fall.
- Fall restraint systems: Designed to prevent a worker from reaching a fall hazard.
Important Note: PPE only minimises the consequence of a fall; it does not prevent the fall itself. It requires specific training, regular inspection, and suitable anchor points, which can be challenging to establish on fragile roofs.
You can learn more about PPE in construction in our blog post Mandatory PPE Requirements for UK Construction Sites.
Planning, Supervision, and Training
Effective prevention relies on more than just equipment:
- Thorough Planning: A detailed Method Statement and Risk Assessment are mandatory for all work involving fragile roofs. This must clearly outline the hazards, control measures, emergency procedures, and roles/responsibilities.
- Competent Personnel: Only individuals who are competent, trained, and authorised should work on or near fragile roofs. This includes training on identifying fragile materials, using specific control measures, and rescue procedures.
- Adequate Supervision: Constant and competent supervision is essential to ensure that safe working practices are followed at all times.
- Emergency Procedures: What happens if someone falls? A clear rescue plan, including the necessary equipment and trained personnel, must be in place.
The Role of Consultancy and Training
This is where specialist health and safety companies become invaluable. We provide:
- Expert Risk Assessments: Identifying and evaluating specific risks associated with fragile roofs on your sites.
- Tailored Method Statements: Developing practical and compliant safe systems of work.
- Work at Height Training: Delivering comprehensive training on all aspects of working at height, including specific modules on fragile roofs, the correct use of access equipment, harnesses, and rescue procedures.
- Auditing and Compliance Checks: Ensuring your practices meet legal requirements and industry best practice.
- Guidance on Equipment Selection: Advising on the most appropriate collective and personal protective equipment for your specific tasks.
Conclusion
Preventing falls through fragile roofs is not merely a matter of regulatory compliance; it is a fundamental commitment to the lives and wellbeing of everyone on a construction site. The "hidden" nature of fragile surfaces, where a sheet of weathered asbestos or a brittle skylight can look deceptively solid, makes them one of the most persistent killers in the UK construction industry.
By prioritizing the hierarchy of control, conducting rigorous risk assessments, and investing in specialist training, companies can eliminate the guesswork that leads to tragedy. Every worker deserves to return home safely at the end of the day, and when it comes to fragile roofs, there is simply no room for shortcuts.
You can learn more about working at height in our informative blog post Working at Height: Best Practices for UK Builders.
Why choose PIP Services for your health and safety training and consultancy?
We’re dedicated to providing the highest level of advice on all Health and Safety related matters and will assist companies in meeting their obligations. We offer a wide range of Health & Safety Services for a variety of clients. We represent many companies and deal with all of their Health & Safety matters.
We’re also an accredited CITB, NEBOSH, IOSH, IWFM & CITB training provider, as well as a ProQual-approved NVQ centre.
We are rated 4.9/5 on Trustpilot, and you can read our reviews here. If you would like to speak to us about your training needs, please get in touch using the button below.